Wednesday, 23 January 2008

PMQs 22 January 2008

Thank you, thank you, thank you...

I don't often get the opportunity to watch PMQs, and in the last couple of months it would appear by all accounts I should probably be grateful because it seems David Cameron has been dishing out a thrashing to Gordon Brown, and he was ably assisted in this by the dry, laid back wit of Vince Cable.

Bob Piper

Dogged resistance from Brown over Northern Rock

In India, Brown was full of beans – boasting at one stage that he’d outlasted Dame Kelly Holmes who had to retire to her hotel. He should have saved his energy. He looked exhausted at PMQs today. Until Cameron piped up on Northern Rock, that was. Then he sprang to life and put up a hell of a fight.

Coffee House

Live PMQs blog from noon

EDITORIAL VERDICT: "Emphatic victory for David Cameron. He talked about the big issues of the week - Northern Rock and economic weakness. He made the Prime Minister look evasive because he failed to answer questions about taxpayer exposure. Nick Clegg even helped the Conservatives by implying that Brown hadn't nationalised the Rock because he was running scared of the Tories. Who's the real opposition now then, Mr Clegg?"

Conservative Home

PMQs - The Verdict

Prime minister's question time was dominated by Northern Rock but with Jacqui Smith's nocturnal snacking in SE15 and Only Fools and Horses being raised, Peckham provided an unlikely sub-plot.

Conservative MP Stephen Crabb began proceedings by asking: "What is happening on Britain's streets when the home secretary needs an armed police escort to go out and buy a kebab?"

ePolitix


The Verdict

Another week and the focus is yet again on Northern Rock. I think ePolitix sums it up best by describing Cameron’s performance as “Another far from devastating six questions on Northern Rock.” I do disagree with them on Brown’s performance however. He was every bit as poor and unconvincing as Cameron. The problem is, neither of these two have any idea what to do about Northern Rock and they both keep changing their minds on a week by week basis.

At least Cameron is sticking to the single issue, ensuring that it gets on the evening news, but as I have said a million times before he is not the polished performer we once thought he might be. Political Betting has an interesting article that really hits the money on Cameron’s PMQs performances. He has a clip up there of Blair taking on Major back in the 1990s. Blair looks hungry, as though he means it, is incredibly measured and puts the knife in brilliantly. The way he delivers the line “Weak..Weak..Weak” is so damning and convincing it doesn’t matter whether Major is weak or not – we all believe Blair. He makes Major look weak. Cameron has to up his game to this level if he is ever going to really take on Brown and finish him off. Until then, PMQs is just going to be a playground slanging match where both competitors disappoint.

All the tools and ammunition are there for Cameron. Now he just needs to learn how to use them.

On another point – Nick Clegg. Who side is he on? Labours? The Tories? He doesn’t appear to be on the side of the Lib Dems. First he decides to back the government over the EU Treaty referendum. Then today he does the Tories ground work for them by telling Brown he is "running scared of the Conservative Party." It went down a treat with the Tory benches. A poor start for the new leader in my book. Bring back Vince!

Brown 0.5


Cameron 0.5

The Late Lunch Briefing

The Rock crisis continues...

It’s the issue that just won’t go away. Northern Rock. Once again they clashed over the Rock at PMQs today (more on that later with the PMQs Battle round up at 5pm). Remember, this all started way back before the Conference season when Brown was flying (or bouncing) high in the polls. Back then we all thought it would pass and it was a bit of a non-issue. People even started throwing money in to the Rock as they thought the share price would recover once the government had backed it. Oh how things have changed since those late summer days...

Does anyone have the answer?

The government’s latest idea is to issue bonds and let Richard Branson take it on. Last week we were all firmly set for nationalisation. Next week – who knows? The Tories haven’t been much better – I am as unsure as to what their position is on this as I am the governments. To watch the two leaders argue about in PMQs today was ridiculous – both accusing the other of “flip flopping”. The truth is they both are. This has been an almighty balls up and no-one, it seems, has the answer of what to do. Meanwhile the crisis goes on and the bills (covered by the tax payer) continue to rack up. Have we reached a point in UK politics where no-one is up to the job?

Where have all the Big Beasts gone?

Rather like a poor intake in one year at school or in the military, is the class of 2008 just not very good? Back in the 1980s it was Labour who were just not very good. In the 1990s it was the Tories who were not very good. In the Brown era it seems that mediocrity of our main party leaders and front benches is the best we are going to. Where are the giants of old? The big beast? The Wilsons, the Hurds? The Heseltines? Dare I say it, where are the Blairs and the Thatchers? You may not like them, but at least they were decisive and strong. We have now probably the most indecisive PM we have ever had. This man makes Chamberlain look strong. Opposite him we have a man who just appears to lack the conviction of a man who not only really believes what he is saying but really wants the top job.

Maybe this is some sort of distorted nostalgia, where the past always seems better than the present. But somehow I just cannot see anyone on either side of the house who is offering hope and a vision for the Britain. As I said, sometimes you just get a bad intake. Or perhaps Cameron or Miliband just aren’t quite ready to step up to the plate. Either way, whoever it is who can capture the imagination of the British public again will surely be destined to be the next Big Beast and our new PM.

About The Poliblogs

Seeing as I have made a few changes to the blog and developed it some what since I first launch in July 2007, it seems about time I explained what the Poliblogs is about and the features on the blog:

The Daily Round Up:

The main daily feature of the blog is my daily roundup of what I consider to be the best political posts in the blogosphere. I monitor about 200 blogs on a daily basis and take the cream of the crop and share them with you. I try to ensure that I take a balanced view by taking a range of opinions on the major issues of the day from the whole political spectrum.


The Late Lunch Briefing:

The Late Lunch Briefing is new to the Poliblogs for this year. It is my daily column where I tackle the major political issue or issues of the day adding my opinion and hopefully a little insight. I try to get this up by around 2pm daily.

The PMQs' Battle
Every Wednesday, when the House is sitting, I do a daily round up of what the blogosphere thought of that day's PMQs. I also add my own take on proceedings and then score the battle. I have been doing this since Brown took over as PM and so the tally (in the right hand column) is a total of every meeting Cameron & Brown have had. This is posted at 5pm every Wednesday.

A View Across The Pond


Another new feature to the Poliblogs - every Tuesday at 2pm I will post my take on the US presidential election.





The Blog of the Week Award

Every Monday morning I hand out the "coveted" Poliblogs Blog of the Week Award - my top three blogs of the week. Hopefully it will introduce my readers to a new blog or two and also recognises who I think are at the very top of their game in the political blogging world.



Politics Decoded

Politics Decoded is my weekly Tuesday column I write on the Wardman Wire blog for Matt Wardman. It is a longer version of the Late Lunch Briefing, in effect. It is my take on the major political issues of that week. I re-post the column 24hours later on the Poliblogs.

Other Stuff
I also occasionally post other things - the odd video, link, piece of opinion...

If there is anything else you'd like me to cover on the Poliblogs, all ideas are very welcome!

Blogpower & Daily Round Up developments


I recently applied to become a member of Blogpower, which is a community of bloggers who actively support each other and promote each others' blogs. It is for the smaller bloggers out there, rather than the Iain Dales and Political Bettings of this world.

I am very pleased to say my application has been approved and I am now a member.

I have added the blogroll of all the other members of Blogpower in the right hand column - please take a look at some the the blogs on there when you have some time.

I am very aware that my own blog roll is starting to get a bit out of date with some blogs now defunct and other new ones coming out that I am enjoying and have added to the daily roundup but not my blogroll.

In the next couple of weeks I will be doing a complete review and a culling exercise - taking out the old and bringing in some new. I expect that overall I will be having a net gain in the number of blogs I monitor. I will keep you up to date with the developments and let you know who I have added (when I have added them). I suspect a few from Blogpower will be added to the daily roundup.

In the meantime, if you have any suggestions as to a great blog that I should be reading, then let me know either in the comments or by email - poliblogsAThotmail.co.uk

The Poliblogs 23 Januray 2008

Beyond Our Ken

The interesting thing about the sudden "Decent Bat-Signal" (thanks to Alex in comments for this phrase) that now is Fuck Ken Time, is that they don't appear to be endorsing any alternative candidate. Why not? A glance at the slate reveals that all the alternatives to Ken are politically ... difficult for the Decents to love:

Aaronovitch Watch

Throwing mud at the mayor

Recent attacks by journalists on Ken Livingstone have obscured the issues by which he - and his rivals - should be judged

Dave Hill

Dispatches on “The Court of Ken”

Like many people, I tuned into the Dispatches investigation of the office of the Mayor of London, or more specifically the way Ken Livingstone has conducted himself and the people he has surrounded himself with. martin_bright_140×140.jpgThe programme was led by Martin Bright, Political Editor of the New Statesman, and opened with Peter Tatchell (whom I know from the Doughty Street days as a very passionate campaigner and generally serious dude) saying:

Mike Rouse

Nick Clegg must prove we trust the British people on Europe

Whilst the Lib Dems news policy of a referendum on out continued membership of the EU might be inspired, it serves merely to gloss over the fact that we promised a referendum on the EU Constitution, and as has been shown by various reliably sources, the EU reform Treaty is virtually identical to the EU constitution. So shouldn't we support the referendum we promised ? Others I know feel the same way too.

Norfolk Blogger

Lisbon Treaty: referendum, please

The Lisbon Treaty, at least to my eyes, looks much like the EU constitution dressed up in the political equivalent of a fur coat and Trinny and Susannah Original Magic Knickers. For the uninitiated, T&S Original Magic Knickers – available from Littlewoods here – promise instantly to transform the larger lady into a svelte beauty who will knock the guys dead as soon as she dons her little black number. But there’s just one snag, girls; a backside the size of a small planet, even when crammed into doubtlessly wonderful elasticated underwear, remains a fat arse.

Dave’s Part

The dangerous uselessness of 'Euroscepticism'

Here we go again, another festival of pointless calls for a referendum on the EU constitution. The whole thing reminds me of dogs chasing cars. What would they do if they caught them? What would happen if they held a referendum, and everyone voted ‘No’? Well, we already know. Nothing good. Ask the people of France, Ireland and the Netherlands, all of whom at various times have said 'No' to EU plans. They've either been sent back to do it again and come up with the right answer, or they have been ignored. And then what do they do?

Peter Hitchens

None of our business

Liberal-Democrat leader Nick Clegg has declared that he and his party will NOT support a referendum on the Lisbon Treaty, the one declared by many to be almost identical with the EU constitution voted down in France and the Netherlands. This is hardly surprising since I remember him on television at the time saying the "no" votes didn't count "because polls have shown that the French and Dutch voters didn't know what they were voting about."

Adam Smith

Brown no longer gets the benefit of the doubt

If you had told most people in the Westminster Village a year ago that the economy would hit choppy waters, then most people would have thought that this would actually strengthen Gordon Brown’s electoral position. The logic behind this was that Labour’s advantage on the economic competence question was so deep set that the public would prefer Brown’s experienced hand at the tiller rather than the untested Cameron and Osborne combination.

Coffee House

The rules haven't changed

Change the world: Believe it or not, New Labour is beginning to make sense on terrorism, now Tony Blair has gone

Sunny Hundal

Will it ever get as bad as this for Gordon?

According to a report in the Independent yesterday Gordon Brown is telling friends that the public is being increasingly repelled by PMQs and that the Commons exchanges are now of little use in discussing the issues of the day. He’s reported as saying that “nothing prepares you” for the ferocity of a packed chamber in full cry” and that the weekly event is worse than it has ever been. I’m not so sure. The above short video shows a couple of exchanges between Tony Blair and John Major in the period before the 1997 election when, of course, Blair was asking the questions. The “Weak..Weak..Weak” refrain has become famous and shows Blair at his most aggressive. I do not think that Cameron has yet matched this in his exchanges with Gordon.

Political Betting

Mark Field MP: Northern Rock has been nationalised in all but name

For sure there have been more spectacular banking crises than that which has affected Northern Rock in recent months. The phenomenon of a ‘run on the bank’ was almost commonplace in Victorian times. More recently the collapse of BCCI (1991) and Barings (1995) show that even a highly regulated banking sector is never immune to mismanagement and fraudulent activity.

Conservative Home

Tuesday, 22 January 2008

A View Across the Pond

So far the presidential candidates’ race has all been about Clinton, Obama and the Democrats. The Republicans have had a few moments in the limelight, but overall we have been enthralled by these two brilliant performers. The Oscar nominations have just been announced today and it wouldn’t have come as a surprise if Clinton had been nominated as best crying actress or Obama as best male speech.

You can tell that things are hotting up in the Democrat’s presidential candidate race – the final two (John Edwards is surely out of it) – and it’s getting more and more personal. In a televised debate yesterday the two ripped in to each other as Edwards sat back and watched. But the two of them are going to have to take a back seat when the action moves to Florida. While we have been enthralled with the Democrat’s race, it is actually the Republican race that is even wider open and more interesting. Is the biggest gamble of all the primaries about to pay off for Rudy Giuliani?

Giuliani’s strategy had been to take a back seat in the other states and put everything he has in to Florida in the hope that that would be enough to get him the nomination. If he fails to win in Florida it is as good as over for him. And it looks like his gamble may not be paying off. A Rasmussen poll of voters throughout the US has him in joint fourth place on 10%, 15 points behind the front-runner, John McCain on 25%. Is this the end of the hero of New York? Well, to rub salt in the wound, even his home state of New York appear to have lost the faith. A Siena College poll puts him on 24%, 12 points behind Mr McCain on 36%. And the pollsters are rarely wrong on these sorts of things... d’oh!

So on to Florida where it seems we have no idea who will win as you can’t trust the polls, followed by Super Tuesday (or Tsunami Tuesday as it is known this year due to the number of primaries taking place) where we should be left with some answers to one of the most complex and long winded election processes in the world. It’s fun to watch, but thank God they do don’t do it here!

The Poliblogs 22 January 2008

No-one likes him but he don't care...

I wrote a couple of days ago about Nick Clegg and 'behind closed doors' electoral pacts. At least the Lib Dem candidate for London Mayor is putting his cards on the table. Brian Paddick, following the news that a poll for the Evening Standard (surprise, surprise, large pinch of salt over shoulder) puts Boris Johnson on 44%, Ken Livingstone on 38%, himself on 12% and the Green candidate on 4% of first preference votes, said:

Bob Piper

Absolutely

Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. So said Lord Acton in 1887. Could he have been thinking of the office of Mayor of London? I have just watched Martin Bright's Dispatches on Channel 4. I had not realised the sheer scale of the waste inflicted by Mayor Livingstone. If even half the allegations Bright made are true then Livingstone deserves to be toast at the May elections. He has set up "embassies" in China and India and plans to open one in Venezuela. These alone cost London taxpayers millions a year.

Edland

Who do we support for London Mayor?

Given Martin Bright’s documentary on Channel 4 last night (I was out, didn’t get to watch), who should be supported for London Mayor? Ken is still the only left-wing candidate for London. Paddick is somewhat leftist on some issues and Boris Johnson is an annoying buffoon. I’d rather eat my monitor than support the latter. Fellow conspirator Dave Osler’s written this defence of Socialist Action and isn’t a fan of Nick Cohen, saying:

Liberal Conspiracy

Vote Ken with no illusions

I've just watched the Martin Bright programme on Ken Livingstone on Channel 4's Dispatches. I didn't think much of it as a piece of journalism - superficial, one-sided and in places - such as criticising Ken for promoting London to the EU, China and India, or for spending money on advertising and PR, just silly. The parading of a disillusioned ex-employee, Lib Dem MP Lynne Featherstone, and Mark Wadsworth (who I believe has an axe to grind) was hardly illuminating.

Luke’s Blog

The Guardian turns on Ken

The Guardian leader today gets to the essence of the Ken Livingstone issue: "He performed brilliantly in the wake of the July 7 bombs, a unifying source of strength and common sense. But since that moment, surely the high point of his career, his habit of sustained insurgency has slid into an unattractive and partisan arrogance." And their conclusion? "But if Mr Livingstone wants to hold on to office, he should stop picking fights with the very many Londoners who hope that he can mend his ways. Holding the capital hostage with the understandable threat that Mr Johnson will be worse is a foolish way to test the public's patience."

Harry’s Place

How much silver, Martin?

This is one of those occasions when my fingers pummel the keys on my laptop so hard they nearly embed themselves in the circuit boards. Where do I begin? Today the New Statesman's political editor has used a column in the Evening Standard to call on voters to kick Labour's London Mayor out of office. That's not the Political Editor of The Spectator. It's the New Statesman. Yep, their meant to be on our side.

Labourhome

Our government has spoken

While the House of Commons was busy giving away more powers to our central government in Brussels, that government was sending out a stern message to Mr Darling, our state treasurer, that he had better watch his step over Northern Rock. The Forbes financial news agency was one of the very few to carry the report, which has the EU commission saying it will "analyse under strict EU aid rules" any new British government support for Northern Rock.

EU Referendum

Descent into recession?

Global stock-markets have plummeted today, with the FTSE 100 share index suffering its largest one-day drop since September 11th, 2001; losing more than 5% of its value. The falls – which are being mirrored by rapid price drops for commodities such as oil – are being spurred by a fear of a recession in the US.

Coffee House

Could this change things on both sides of the Atlantic?

Who’ll come out best when there is so much uncertainty? After a day which saw the Northern Rock bailout plan, the start of the EU treaty process in the Commons and the Channel 4 programme on Ken’s record as Mayor these are the headlines in the “serious” papers this morning. It’s hard to focus on a specific political theme because, as Simon Hoggart in the Guardian puts is “..Outside in the real world the stock market was melting down..”

Political Betting

Go back to Gorbals, Mick

For how much longer do we have to be saddled with the inept Michael Martin as Speaker of the House of Commons? Gorbals Mick should never have been Speaker in the first place: by convention, Betty Boothroyd should have been followed by an opposition MP but the Labour whips chose to ignore convention for reasons of partisan self-interest.

Blaney’s Blarney

Vince Cable - the people's hero

Many thanks indeed to Stephen Tall on Liberal Democrat Voice for highlighting Vince Cable's Commons speech on Northern Rock this afternoon. It is priceless. A devastating and hilarious critique of the government. It should be framed. I make no apologies for repeating it:

Liberal Burblings

Yesterday’s EU Treaty proceedings explained

Yesterday’s vote and proceedings in the Commons show the grim reality that unless the Lib Dems honour their promise of a referendum there is no chance of us gaining one. Yesterday was the Second Reading. The issue was simply – do you want this Bill and this Treaty at all? Conservatives and 19 Labour rebels voted against the Bill and Treaty in its entirely. Lib Dems and the rest of the Labour party voted for it, giving them a huge majority.

John Redwood

Miliband: ‘Bishops support the Treaty of Lisbon’

To Cranmer’s total incredulity (and, judging by the howls of laughter, to that of the entire House of Commons), this was a line which the Foreign Secretary gave to the House of Commons as evidence for the innate goodness of the Treaty of Lisbon, and as a substantive reason for the House to support it. His Grace is dumbfounded:

Cranmer

Second reading of the EU (amendment) Bill.

The debate into the second reading of the EU (amendment) Bill as started and Miliband is getting a good old fashioned roasting. Ian Paisley made a very good statement when he pointed out that the governments of Scotland and Northern Ireland are against the Treaty.

Daily Referendum

The referendum question

I have to admit to remaining of the view that if the Lib Dems are in favour of a referendum on our continued membership of the EU, which we apparently are, then if that option looks as if it will get nowhere (which it does) we should be supporting the next best option, a referendum on the Reform Treaty. The fact that we’ve consistently failed to enthuse the public about the EU should not be a reason for refusing to face the music.

Quaequam Blog!

Parliament at its worst

If you want to understand why MPs are so unpopular, take a close look now. Today, the House of Commons began the process of ratifying a treaty that not one of its 646 members has read. I say this with some certainty, because I have spent months trying to keep up with the text, whose clauses are regularly shuffled around and renumerated more or less for the sole purpose of confusing its critics. I am like a cartoon character with straining matchsticks propping up my eyelids.

Daniel Hannan

Sheffield Tories claim Nick Clegg’s ‘first clanger’

Sheffield’s Tories appear to be continuing their crusade to cut poverty and health inequality in Sheffield by getting street lights repaired more promptly, roads repaired a little quicker (which in Sheffield will still be an age) and by cutting the grass in local parks a bit more. The reason I say this now is because of a bizarre attack by a former Sheffield Tory, (now living in Brent), Richard Holloway, where he accuses Nick Clegg of ‘dropping a clanger’ because he believes that improving the health of the city’s population might be just that little more complicated than their proposals.

Anders Hanson

Politics Decoded

Go over to the Wardman Wire to read this week's Politics Decoded column...