Thursday, 23 August 2007

Is this for real?!

Baptists for Brownback 2008

I have stumbled across this blog (via b3ta). It appears to be some extremist Christian Americans who are backing Sam Brownback for president - and laying in to the Brits in the process. I am pretty sure it's a wind-up, but it's hard to tell at times - particularly some of the comments! It is car crash reading - some of the most dislikeable people airing their opinions , yet very hard to tear yourself away from it. Quite amusing too!

The Poliblogs 23rd August 2007

Why the state won't shrink

The CityUnslicker asks, mournfully, "Will taxes ever be cut in the UK?"

In my view, not by any significant amount, the reason being that people expect the state to do more now than they did, say, thirty years ago. This was an insight gained through my brief experience of working in the public sector.

Pub Philosopher

Have the Newbie's Been Promoted Too Early?

I'm doing some research for an article I am writing for Parliamentary Monitor magazine (published at the party conferences) and I have calculated that of the 52 Conservative MPs elected for the first time in 2005*, a massive 30 of them now have positions on the front bench - three of them in the shadow cabinet.

Iain Dale

Cameron fails to convince Tories of his electability

Writing in today's Independent, Michael Brown suggests that David Cameron has failed to even convince his own team that he can win the next General Election.

The main evidence for this is the comparative inactivity of the Tory front bench with that of Labour during the summer of 1996:

Peter Black

Conservatives ARE the Agenda

I had said some time ago that I felt it was complacency on the part of "Team Cameron" that led to the shaky start to the Brown Premiership for the opposition. Whereas the LibDems took the novel approach of saying and doing nothing - which, to be fair, has paid off - the Conservatives got themselves tangled up in all sorts and ended up 10 points behind the polls.

Little’s Log

Tories will fight next election on social - not economic – issues

David Cameron gives a revealing interview to today's Yorkshire Post in which he puts social breakdown at the heart of the Conservative pitch for the next General Election:

Conservative Home

Louise Bagshawe: Reasons to vote Conservative

Moving house is always a stressful thing. In our case, we are this week preparing for a move into the constituency. I was always clear that being a parliamentary candidate meant total commitment to the area you hope to represent. Our family story is just one amongst thousands – Conservative activists giving up their time, knocking on doors, standing as local councillors, donating, writing to the local paper, marching for their local hospitals, serving in their Associations, even starting blogs! We are a team. And when we are united we are an unstoppable team.

Conservative Home

The Sick Man of Europe

Yesterday, evidence was presented that confirmed that Britain is once more the sick man of Europe (see table above). Despite record increases in NHS expenditure since Labour came to power, British cancer mortality rates still rank amongst the lowest in Europe. The Lancet Oncology Journal claimed, on the basis of their figures, that the government's cancer plan introduced in 2000 in England (2001 in Scotland) was not working. Cancer charities have since cited the absence of proper radiotherapy services as a major cause of poor survival rates. Tellingly, the report called for a "fundamental assessment of the ways in which the NHS operates".

Philip Lee

Loose interpretations

Andrew Anthony scores several direct hits in his critique of the liberal left, but he should try to develop a deeper understanding of true liberalism.

Will Hutton

Is Labour about to lose its poll lead?

Could Nick Palmer be right about the next round of surveys?

In a post last night Nick Palmer - the Labour MP for Broxtowe and the first of any party to contribute to Politicalbetting under his own name - made an extraordinary prediction about the next round of polls.

Political Betting

The Tories' 'dodgy' hospital dossier?

The Tory leader is - yet again - on the defensive, this time over the accuracy of his party's list of proposed hospital closures and downgradings .

As per usual the problems for Mr Cameron have come mainly from within. Henry Bellingham, the shadow justice minister and MP for Norfolk North West, told the BBC that the Queen Elizabeth hospital in King’s Lynn should not have been “singled out” for inclusion on the Conservatives’ list. “Obviously a mistake has been made and as the local MP I wasn’t consulted on this and I apologise unreservedly to the staff of the hospital,” he said.

Labour Home

Sharpen Up!

Arthur Ma discusses his disapproval of David Cameron.

Now I know it’s hardly my place to berate Our Dear Leader ™ but David Cameron really ought to sharpen up. With the amount of gaffes he is accumulating he is turning out to be more like Bush than Blair.

18 Doughty Street

Mickey Mouse degrees are just the job

OK then, let's have a good snigger. Let's all look at the list of these so-called degrees, and sneer at the pathetic delusions of the students who are taking them. In the saloon bars of England, it is by now a settled conviction that the university system is riddled with a kind of intellectual dry rot, and it is called the Mickey Mouse degree.

Boris Johnson

No certainties

The German leader, Angela Merkel is making her first visit to No 10 during Gordon Brown's premiership. (You might remember it's not the first time they have met as leaders - Gordon Brown raised a few eyebrows by choosing to go first to Berlin as PM, rather than across the pond to visit George W Bush).

I'm told the two leaders are discussing health matters in the developing world. But what is not officially on the agenda, and what at the beginning of the summer Gordon Brown didn't really fancy talking about either, is the draft EU reform treaty.

Nick Robinson (Laura Kuenssberg)

Are we out of step on Europe?

Gordon Brown has rejected calls for a UK referendum on the replacement for the EU constitution, despite it being called for this time by labour supporting Unions.

There was one important quote in the BBC report which led me to think the party is out of step on Europe and needs to get its message across loud and clear. The line was:

Norfolk Blogger

Norman Lamb and Facebook: descent into farce

OK, this started off rather seriously - someone faking a Norman Lamb MP profile on Facebook. It then got rather bizarre when the computer used to send emails out from the linked fake Homtial address was also used to post comments from eight different aliases to this site trying to shift the blame to UKIP, Labour and the Liberal Democrats (but never the Conservatives).

Lib Dem Voice

A month of silver linings

From the absence of John Reid to the elimination of ITN gimmicks, August hasn't been all bad

David McKie

Wednesday, 22 August 2007

The Poliblogs 22nd August 2007

Will taxes ever be cut in the UK?

As we edge close to the next recession (or Depression, depending on how much the financiers screw everything up), alarm bells are ringing in my head about the future that taxpayers face

City Unslicker

How seriously should we take the terrorist threat?

Econlog repeats the claims of John Mueller that the threat from terrorism is being taken too seriously. Bryan Caplan, the brilliant analyst who is one of the two men behind Econlog, argues that we have enough data now to be clear that the risk posed by terrorists is small in the scheme of things.

Daniel Finkelstein

Why can’t researchers get their facts right?

David Cameron has made an embarrassing error by wrongly claiming that maternity services at King’s Lynn’s Queen Elizabeth Hospital were under threat in his latest high profile announcement of NHS reforms. The fault was blamed on a typing error, according to this report in the Eastern Daily Press.

Ellee Seymour

Labelling Boris a bigot is pathetic

The Guardian reports today that Compass, the leftwing pressure group, has compiled a dossier accusing Boris of being “Norman Tebbit in a clown’s uniform”. Well, now: I admire Norman and hate clowns with equal vigour, and so find this an intrinsically distasteful notion. But the strategy adopted by Compass – namely that Our Candidate is a crypto-fascist – is very good news for his campaign.

Coffee House

Alexander wins one horse race

And then there was one. One candidate for the Scottish Labour leadership, that is. For the avoidance of doubt, that candidate is Wendy Alexander.

She received nominations from 41 out of 46 Labour MSPs. And she knows the names of the infamous five. Only joking.

Blether with Brian

Cameron repeats call to scrap Human Rights Act

The Press Association is reporting that the Conservative leader has repeated his call for the Human Rights Act to be scrapped and replaced with a British Bill of Rights. Interviewed by BBC radio in the West Midlands he accused Labour of being "blind" to the HRA's failings.

Conservative Home

Human rights have actually taken away our liberty

The state does not give us rights and I don't believe in human rights because they do not exist. There, I said it. This might cause outrage amongst some people. In fact for some I imagine it will be taken as evidence of my crypto-fascism. This is an unfortunate by-product of the intellectual atmosphere in which we now live (certainly in the UK) when the subject of those ever so emotional human rights are discussed.

Dizzy Thinks

How society has failed Frances Lawrence

Frances Lawrence has been doing the rounds on TV and radio today, expressing her outrage at the fact that her husbands murderer will not now be deported when he finishes his sentence. For liberals, issues such as these place us in a tricky position. No-one wishes to cause Frances Lawrence or her family any further grief, but what if pretty much everything she says is utterly wrong?

Quaequam Blog

Scrapping the Human Rights Act

The Human Rights Act is a British Bill of Rights, isn't it? It's simply the expression in British law of he European Convention on Human Rights....which, even if we repeal that specific Act still holds true. All that changes is that instead of using the British courts to get such rights enforced, people would have to use the European ones. Do correct me if I'm wrong, but that's the situation, isn't it?

Further, I'm not even all that sure that it's this Act that is the problem here. Isn't it, rather, EU law: the freedom of movement of people? As he's an EU citizen, we can't deport him (or even if we can, we can't stop him coming back)?

Tim Worstall

Deportation, EU Law and Human Rights

The Italian man convicted of murdering Philip Lawrence has been successful in avoiding deportation, horrifying many. Two things call for comment:

Live Journal

Laughing all the way to City Hall

Boris Johnson's perceived buffoonishness is exactly why many people like him. Labour may need a different point of attack in the mayoral election race.

Michael White

Vote for holidays!

A proposal for extra public holidays might seem at odds with recent Conservative statements, but it would be ripe for the picking by Labour.

Brendan Barber

Prezza To Announce Retirement as MP Saturday

The Hull Daily Mail is reporting that Prezza will tell constituency activists at a party at his home on Saturday that he intends to step down as an MP. After trousering £300,000 for his memoirs (ghost written obviously) this was always on the cards.

Guido Fawkes

Has the media got wise to Gord’s policy stealing?

It struck me while re-watching this on the net a couple of night’s ago that something significant was happening. That the standard Brown approach of closing down debates by stealing popular policies from his opponents might not be so easy in the future.

Political Betting

Bonkers Conkers and Health and Safety: Response from the Institution of Occupational Health and Safety

I have had a detailed response from the Institution of Occupational Safety and Health to my article “Do Health and Safety Professionals Get too Much of a Kicking?” I reproduce it full here.

I am absorbing the large number of detailed comments made on the posting, and the discussion in the Public Forum on the IOSH website, and will post a considered response in a couple of days.

The Wardman Wire

Hold Brown accountable, draw up some doorstep policies and get a little bit angry

Hold Brown accountable for the Blair-Brown years. A member of my family told me last week that they would be voting for Gordon Brown. They've voted Conservative at the last few elections but felt that Brown deserved "a fair go". It's urgent that we tackle this. Conservatives need to make it clear that Brown has been at Blair's side for every big decision that has been taken since 1997.

Conservative Home

What did the Tories say about this?

Some months ago, the distinguished academic Sir Peter Williams accepted that 'A' levels had grown easier. This is significant, because Sir Peter had just been chosen by Gordon Brown to take charge of overhauling maths exams in schools. Dr Robert Coe of Durham University has also produced convincing research that establishes the existence of grade inflation beyond doubt.

Peter Hitchens

In defense of 'Mickey Mouse degrees'

Three cheers for Universities UK, who have today hit back at those siren voices who have been systematically grabbing cheap headlines by attacking legitimate degree subjects. They have responded to a report by the Taxpayers’ Alliance, an umbrella group that lobbies for lower taxes and allegedly highlights public sector “waste” to support its case, which has singled out two Welsh institutions – the University of Glamorgan and the Welsh College of Horticulture – for issuing “non-degrees”.

Peter Black

The "Facebook Faker" is revealed... as a stupid person

Having been at first quite irritated by this, you may have guessed that I now find this whole thing very very amusing. And just in case my day looked like it may have been dull, what pops into my email box but a message from the "Facebook Faker"! Oh yes - it came from the famous norman_lamb@hotmail.co.uk e-mail address and this is what it said:

Little’s Blog

Tuesday, 21 August 2007

The Poliblogs 21st August


Daniel Finkelstein: Convince voters that the changes of the last eighteen months
are real and will continue

Keep calm. For two reasons. First, because all new Prime Ministers have a honeymoon, there's nothing you can do about it and it won't last forever. Second, because the electorate like you but worry about the party. They therefore need to believe that you are strong. Given your character serenity and optimism is the best way to convey this.

Conservative Home

My Two Cents...on the Heathrow protests

With fawning excitement, the BBC has paid excessive attention to the sordid collection of hippies, pot smokers and anarchists who are protesting at Heathrow Airport against freedom of movement of our citizenry. They oppose the third runway at Heathrow, and passengers flying overseas, because of the supposed damage likely to be caused to the environment by so-called greenhouse gases.

Enough is Enough

The tent commandments

The Camp for Climate Action has certainly caught our attention, but has it made you think twice about flying abroad? What will you do instead?

Comment is Free

When Green goes Goofy

I believe people should be environmentally conscious. I believe people should make every rational effort to protect and preserve our planet's environment, conserve non-renewable resources, discover and use energy sources and raw materials that minimise pollution, and which are renewable or recyclable. That's just common sense.

But what I'm finding increasingly annoying are "Green" busy-bodies whose remonstrations are so irrational that they risk turning the average person off being 'green' at all. A case in point.

Harry’s Place


David Cameron - Comes Out Fighting At Last.

Having returned from his holiday, David Cameron has at last started a decent attack on Labour policy and we should now see an end to the unfathomable Brown bounce. David said: "They want to see their district general hospital improved and people simply do not understand why maternity units and accident and emergency units are being shut down - when actually accident and emergency admissions are actually up and births are up."

Daily Referendum

‘Tory Fight back’ – No, really…

So David Cameron is promising a ‘bare knuckle fight' against Gordon Brown. AND tax cuts. AND he'll save the NHS. Oh, and he’s going to stop knife crime.

Now, ambition is always to be welcomed and all these issues are important to most voters but what is so clearly lacking from the Conservatives is any kind of clear vision. They simply don’t look like they know what they are doing.

Wit & Wisdom

Can he ignore the popular press?

It was The Sun which, as always, distilled the message down to its bare essentials – that "thousands of Labour voters will desert Gordon Brown at the next general election if he refuses to hold a referendum on the EU constitution". Thus we learn that almost a quarter of the party's life-long supporters - 24 percent - say "they will kick the PM in the ballot box unless they get a vote".

EU Referendum

What’ll be the political consequences of a Basra pull-out?

So how is this going to affect domestic politics? Will Gordon get the kudos for finally closing down Britain’s Iraq involvement that was started by his predecessor? Or will this open up again the debate on how the UK got into this position in the first place?

Could a grand pull-out gesture by Brown be part of an early general election campaign. If so how can it be made palatable when there are so many, like the cleric quoted above, who would try to present it as a defeat?

Political Betting

What's not to like about politics?

I know I shouldn’t and it’s very displeasing when others to do it, but, I’d like a moan. Here is a short list of the really vexing things about having an interest in current affairs. Hopefully, some will hit home and there’ll be the discovery that I’m not alone. There may even be widespread agreement, a critical mass of like minded people leading to a resolution that something is done about some of them – the assertion that democracy works!!! Or perhaps, an interesting thread on LabourHome…

Labour Home

New attack on Johnson paints him as Tebbit in a clown's costume

The left-wing Compass group today gives a taste of the attack that Boris Johnson can expect should he become the Tory nominee for Mayor of London. Compass attempt to paint Mr Johnson as Norman Tebbit in a clown's costume. The Guardian highlights the attempt to substantiate Mr Johnson as holding sexist and out-of-date views and likely, therefore, to damage the 'progressive consensus' of London:

Conservative Home

Will "Boris is a racist" really fly?

It looks like those advising and supporting Ken Livingstone, the Mayor of London, are determined to blackguard his prospective Tory opponent Boris Johnson by any means necessary.

First we had Doreen Lawrence (who has been cultivated by race-activists over the last decade to the point of co-option) wheeled out in The Guardian, to wave her son's shroud and say:

Samizdata

Time to prune back the quangos

Trevor Kavanagh’s column in The Sun today contains one of those facts that makes you stop and re-read the sentence to make sure you’ve understood it correctly. Kavanagh calculates that,

Coffee House Blog

The Non-Courses Report 2007

The TaxPayers’ Alliance has compiled Britain’s first ever list of university “non-courses” – university degrees that lend the respectability of scholarly qualifications to non-academic subjects – and calculated their annual cost to students and taxpayers.

The Tax Payers’ Alliance

Who was the person who faked the Norman Lamb Facebook profile? (Updated)

Assemble the following pieces of evidence about the faking of a Norman Lamb group and profile on Facebook and draw your conclusions:

a. The fake Facebook profile gave as Norman’s email address norman_lamb@hotmail.co.uk

This isn’t a genuine email address for Norman or any of this staff.

b. Emails have been sent from that email address to various people.

Lib Dem Voice

More Tory sock-puppetry and smears

Mark Pack (LibDemVoice) - Who was the person who faked the Norman Lamb Facebook profile?

Some lovely detective work by Mark. I have a couple of details and observations to add:

82.118.116.193 is the IP address connected so strongly to the Facebook impersonation. This is a *static* IP address used for DSL customers of KeConnect. It could be that more than one person is working on this, but only one user account is involved.

Bloggerheads

Hello 82.118.116.193

Domain Name keme.net ? (Network)

IP Address 82.118.116.193 ? (KeConnect ADSL Subscribers)

ISP KeConnect Systems Limited

Location Continent : Europe

Country : United Kingdom (Facts)

State/Region : Suffolk

City : Ipswich

Lat/Long : 52.0833, 1.1667 (Map)

Distance : 62 miles

Duncan Barrowman

Monday, 20 August 2007

The Weekend Poliblogs 18th & 19th August 2007

Right on tax

John Redwood and George Osborne may be engaged in a debate, but the Conservatives are still the party of lower taxation.

Tim Montgomerie

The politics of Planet Osborne

Fascinating post by Tim Montgomerie on Comment is Free. He starts by endorsing (as I do) the need for a low tax economy and then concludes:

Daniel Finkelstein

Osborne: There'll be no Tory promise to reduce the overall burden of taxation at the next General Election

I'm just back from the press conference where the Redwood-Wolfson report was launched. The focus of journalists' questions was on tax policy but the report contains many other important economy-boosting recommendations. Read about them here and read George Osborne's full remarks at the launch.

Conservative Home

Tories pursue social justice by abolishing tax 94% of people do not pay

After much heavy trailing, the Conservative policy group on Economic Competitiveness, today finally published its report.

The headline that the Conservatives are pushing is a call for Inheritance Tax to be abolished, on the grounds that too many middle-income earners are now paying it.

Jeremy Hargreaves

Inheritance Tax - We Should Keep It

Redwood ... spent four lines in his report Freeing Britain to Compete, arguing the case for abolitionof "Inheritance tax "

...(IHT) is not a popular tax. This has become even more true as the swift rise of house prices in much of the country has resulted in many people, who could not in any sense be described as rich, suddenly finding that their family will be liable to pay quite substantial amounts upon their estate. We recommend the abolition of inheritance tax." Some time ago Nick Drew forecast that Brown would do it as it is a small revenue tax but a high profile injustice.

Newmania

A tipping point on tax

I aspire to make this the last ToryDiary post on tax for a few days but I make no promises! There is a leader in one of today's newspapers that makes some very interesting points on tax. Here are a few quotations from it:

Conservative Home

Redwood’s tax plans don’t amount to a killer Tory punch

‘It’s the economy, stupid.” So read the sign on President Bill Clinton’s desk to remind him not to repeat the mistake of the man he defeated. George Bush Sr was thought to have spent too much effort on foreign policy, to the neglect of the home base. But the triumph of Gordon Brown is that the economy has hardly featured as an issue in British politics since Labour was elected a decade ago. Last week the Conservatives tried to revive it.

Michael Portillo

EXCLUSIVE: Daily Mirror Caught Trying to Infiltrate Conservative HQ

Well, I know while the cats away the mice usually play, but the Daily Mirror has really excelled itself this week. I can exclusively reveal that they have been caught out trying to infiltrate the chairman's office at Conservative Campaign Headquarters.

Iain Dale

Daily Mirror caught trying to infiltrate Tory HQ

Well what can I say about this over at Iain's blog. Apparently, a Daily Mirror hack called Emily Miller tried to infiltrate the Conservative Party and get herself her a job. She was caught out when someone in CCHQ became suspicious and, as Iain notes, "CCHQ did a computer check and discovered that her Hotmail account had been accessed from a Daily Mirror computer".

Dizzy Thinks

How dim is the Daily Mirror ?

The story about The Daily Mirror trying to infiltrate CCHQ on Iain Dale's blog is slightly disturbing, but also highlights an incompetence in the Mirror which leaves you questioning whether the Mirror can be trusted on any issue.
I am sure the Mirror thought this was a great wheeze, but choosing a journalist whose name was already known, and putting an e-mail address on the application form that could be traced to the Mirror is so dim as to make you think the Mirror wanted to be caught.

Norfolk Blogger

Ideas to improve the health service

In a HSJ survey one wag wrote that his biggest fear for the NHS under Gordon Brown was that he would “try to improve it”
Sadly the wag’s wisdom has gone unnoticed and now this emerges. It takes us across to the Health Foundation, another quango. (I can make the diagnosis as Dame Carol Black is on its board.)

Dr Rant

Give us wings!

Ignore the Heathrow protesters: manmade flight is liberating and enlightening, and that's why so many of us do it.

Brendan O’Neill

Osborne's embrace

The shadow chancellor seems keen to endorse John Redwood's backward-looking taxation plans - it's a mistake.

Tom Clark

Behind the scenes with the Economic Policy Review

I was somewhat surprised to read about the “Redwood Report” in the papers. It was the Conservative party’s Economic Policy Review. A Steering Group and several Sub groups worked away for more than a year. The final proposals were the result of collective discussion between Group members, and in some cases included discussion with Shadow cabinet members responsible for particular areas.

John Redwood

Could withdrawal from Iraq boost chances of an early election ?

According to the Independent, the military have conceded that there is nothing further to be gained from Britain's presence in Iraq and that we should "get out now".
This differs strongly from what the army have been saying for months and make one wonder if thew army has, in the past, been saying what tony Blair wanted it to say, and with a change at the top, now perhaps asking for the truth rather than the propaganda, the armed forces have finally told Gordon Brown what everyone else has known for some time, tat being, we should get out of Iraq with as much haste as possible.

Norfolk Blogger

Inheritance Tax: Tory gain

The reaction from the opposition has been predictable, but I'm afraid the Tories are right about this one. Inheritance Tax should go, or at least be radically reformed, not necessarily for all the reasons John Redwood says it should but because, thanks to the phenomenon of fiscal drag, it has basically become a regressive tax that penalises people who by no stretch of the imagination can be considered rich.

Paul Linford

Is there any value on the general election markets?

For gamblers like me who like to bet short-term in long term markets the big question is what happens if polls start showing a lessening of Labour’s lead. Is that likely to happen and if so when?

Political Betting

Should Deborah advise Gord to gamble on October?

Is there the evidence to make the toughest call in British politics?

This is Deborah Mattinson, joint chief executive of Opinion Leader Research, a pollster for the Labour party for the past two decades and the person who will advise Brown on whether to go for an early general election.

Political Betting

Brown should call early election

Speculation continues that Gordon Brown might be considering calling a snap general election for this autumn. He should.

Yesterday the Observer reported that Brown had called for “a detailed blueprint with 'all options' to give him the opportunity of calling an election within weeks.” Whilst acknowledging that next spring still remains the most likely date, they cite factors in favour of an early poll

Barcharters Anonymous

Should this person even have the vote?

I found it scary but salutary, reading this from a brain-dead correspondent on Dale's blog. The writer unfavourably compared Fox News (which no-one is forced to pay for or watch) with the BBC (for which one is obliged to pay a poll tax or go to jail if you watch it). Having read this a couple of times I can only conclude that the writer is either below GCSE age and in need of better teaching, or works for the BBC.

Prodicus

Cutting to the chase

A few things that bug me about this whole tax-cutting debate…

Coffee House

Will Prezza Spill the beans?

John Prescott is getting £300,000 for his memoirs which will be called Prezza: Pulling No Punches and ghosted by Hunter Davies. Davies, having worked on the Wayne Rooney and Paul Gascoigne autobiographies, will probably find Prescott a refreshingly intelligent subject.

Coffee House

Matthew Parris: At least one solid, distinctively and obviously Conservative policy should be found (but don't retreat on the huggy, green stuff)

DC should not be spooked by talk of an early general election. However strongly Brown might enter such a contest, elections have lives of their own and this Prime Minister is eminently de-railable. Whenever the contest comes, DC should aim off: aim to win, of course, but remember that the best result would be to wing Brown then let Britain see him flap around for a year or two with a shrunk or non-existent majority.

Conservative Home

ICM: 24% of Labour voters could desert over EU referendum

A new ICM poll in the Daily Mail this morning suggest that nearly a quarter of all Labour voters could desert if the Brown government continues to refuse to hold a referendum on the planned EU constitutional changes.

A total of 82% of those questioned said the revised treaty should be ratified by a referendum and not by parliament. Amongst declared Labour supporters 80% backed the referendum idea with 54% of them believing that the EU already “has too much power over the lives of British people.”

Political Betting

Could Europe lose Labour a quarter of their support?

A new ICM poll in the Daily Mail shows 82% of people think the revised EU treaty should be ratified by referendum, rather than left to Parliament. As David Boothroyd rightly pointed out in the comments here over the weekend, that doesn’t necessarily mean much as polls invariably tell pollsters they like referendums on nearly anything you care to name: it is almost the equivalent of asking “do you think your opinion on X should count?” - how many people’s answer will be “Crikey no, I’m a complete numbskull, don’t give me a vote”.

Polling Report

Smoking ban side-effects

So one evening shortly before the start of recess, this young man and his friends are enjoying a few drinks in a bar in Soho, when he sees one of his new “smoking friends” shambling up Greek Street wearing sunglasses. Of course, he was just about to say hello when the MP disappeared into the kind of doorway that any reasonable person might think was the entrance to a brothel. Or else he might be keen on life drawing and in search of “MODELS” for those purposes.

Recess Monkey

Friday, 17 August 2007

The Poliblogs 17th August 2007

Drinking differently

Britain's drinking problem is not how much, but how. It's time for a French lesson.

Agnes Poirier

A general election in October

So, what are Gordon Brown's options for when to call the next general election? Well, he can go for whenever he wants (up to May 2010), that's the idiocy of not having fixed-term governments.

Have been looking at the betting odds for the date of polling day, and in the last couple of days the odds for an election this year have got shorter. Still 3-1 (last time I checked though).

Matt Davies

Islington London’s Caution Capital!

What are they playing at? I would be delighted if any of the failing Police Force in Islington would like to explain to me the following that has just been extracted under the freedom of information act .These are edited highlights of the list of crimes that have been cautioned only.

Newmania

Show me the smoking gun

New figures suggest the smoking ban has produced a pretty small reduction in the number of people who smoke.

But we are told that making people quit is not the point of the legislation. According to a spokesman for the Department of Health:

Daniel Finkelstein

Ah! That delicate frisson of A-level result lesbionics!

I’ve just realised that its taken me until 4pm on A-level results day before seeing my first A-level result blonde (on the front cover of the Evening Standard).

A quick skip around the news websites:

Quaequam Blog

Prudence Brown - Scotland needs you.

Scotsman.com News - Scottish National Party - SNP: on brink of a financial 'black hole'?

THE SNP government is facing a financial crisis, with a potential spending shortfall of up to £2 billion in its budget plans, according to one of Scotland's leading experts in public expenditure.

An Englishman’s Castle

Osborne welcomes Redwood-Wolfson report but declines to commit to its tax recommendations

Interviewed for the Today programme at 8.10am Shadow Chancellor George Osborne gave a broad welcome to the report on economic competitiveness that will be formally launched later today by its co-chairmen, John Redwood MP and Next's Simon Wolfson.

Conservative Home

John Redwood MP: Freeing Britain to compete

Redwood_john Rt Hon John Redwood MP is Co-Chairman of the Economic Competitiveness Policy Group. In this article for ConservativeHome he argues that a more enterprising Britain will also be a freer, greener and more compassionate Britain.

Conservative Home

Is the Tory tax plan a gift to Gordon?

It’s the Tories bad luck that the policy group is reporting in the same week as the stock market collapse is leading to suggestions that the upward trend in house prices might go into reverse.

Political Betting

Under the shade of Redwood

The Conservative party leadership is canny enough to let John Redwood float his deregulatory policies - but too sharp to adopt them.

Michael White

Don't Hold Your Breath

Plaid Cymru Welsh Assembly member Leanne Wood (of whom see this blog passim) is becoming inordinately excited by the wily Alex Salmond’s proposals for a referendum on independence for Scotland. With touching naivete, she is hoping for much the same to happen in Wales.

Writing in today’s Western Mail, Miss Wood enthuses:

David Jones MP

Drop the dead shark!

Scotland has a chance to join the small states that combine entrepreneurial flair with social-democratic responsibility.

Christopher Harvie

Rein in finance

Those who say this is just a stock market wobble that will soon blow over, are in denial.

Larry Elliott

London politics in primary colours?

I find it fascinating that Tories appear to have leapt on this speculation that Labour might be attempting to rig the Conservative primary for London Mayor.

If it is true, then Labour is full of even more morons than I thought. You would have thought they learnt from their attempts to stitch up the Today programme Christmas poll in 1996. There is simply no way they could organise a mass entryist campaign without having to show their hand. There’d have to be a paper trail, an email trail… you know the drill.

Quaequam Blog

Could Cameron’s primary plan be used to stop Boris?

In what could appear an ill-thought out move during the brash days of Cameron’s leadership the Tories decided that their choice for London mayor should be decided by an open primary in which any London voter could take part.

But what sounded like a PR stunt could now be used against the party by its opponents to stop Boris getting on the ballot.

Political Betting

ID Card “FAQs and myths”

The Identity & Passport Service website has some “FAQs and myths” on its website about ID Cards and the National Identity Register. The pages in question can be found at http://www.identitycards.gov.uk/faqs-and-myths.asp

Lets have a look at some of the “FAQs” and “myths”:

Wonko’s World

Telegraph Political Team in Meltdown

As reported here three weeks ago, it seems that the Little and Large blog is dead, it is an ex-blog. Jonathan Isaby and Brendan Carlin seem to have abandoned the idea. Look around some of the other blogs and they are also pretty dead. Ben Brogan at the Daily Mail and Danny Finkelstein at The Times are really the only serious Dead-Tree-Press political bloggers going now.

Guido Fawkes

Thursday, 16 August 2007

The Poliblogs 16th August 2007

The Miliblog is Back...

And this time it is Ed. Guido understands that David wanted to continue blogging but the FCO mandarins explained that whilst it was fine to pontificate about green wonkery on his blog when he was at Defra, blogging about the negotiating strategy with the North Koreans was more problematic.

Guido Fawkes

Billionaire Donor says "I'll bankroll Labour campaign"

The Times reports this morning that a billionaire is prepared to give "as much as he can" to bankroll an early election should Gordon Brown call it.

There has been a lot of talk recently of an early election, and if I were Brown I would certainly go for it as soon as possible given the volatility on the markets and the fear the inflation and interest rate will rise.

Norfolk Blogger

Alan Duncan MP: Gordon's many failures

Gordon Brown must be feeling very happy at the moment. After a lifetime of ambition he has finally reached the top of the greasy poll, and his reaction to floods, bombs and foot and mouth have made him, at least for the moment, king of the bouncy castle.

Conservative Home

Sleep-walking to disaster?

Labour AM, Huw Lewis, has published an on-line pamphlet this morning in which he warns that his party it will “sleepwalk” to electoral disaster at the next Assembly election in 2011 without major changes. It can be read here.

Peter Black

London needs a Liberty Angel

Nannyism and surveillance is utterly ingrained in Londoners lives. We really should be getting fed up by now. Let’s begin with a ride on the tube. A decade ago, when you shoved your ticket into the barrier machine on the way to work, it was your own business. Nobody but you knew where you travelled from, where you were going to, and at what time.

Hot Ginger & Dynamite

So, Farewell Then...

To no-one’s great surprise, Jack McConnell has decided to stand down as leader of the Scottish Labour Party. His decision was seen as inevitable following his party’s defeat at the hands of the SNP in May. It is believed that he had decided to stand down several weeks ago, but had taken the summer to ‘reflect’ – something interpreted widely as code for waiting for a Peerage or a similarly prestigious sinecure elsewhere.

Scots & Independence

Alexander for leader?

One by one, the potential contenders to challenge Wendy Alexander for the Scottish Labour leadership are dropping out.

Margaret Curran, Andy Kerr and Iain Gray have now all declined to enter the contest.

Ms Alexander herself has confirmed that she is a candidate - but won’t launch her campaign until Friday.

Blether with Brian

Louise Bagshawe: Brown's bad news

Louise Bagshawe gazes into her crystal ball and forecasts trouble for the PM...

Conservative Home

My country 'tis of thee ... and thee and thee

Multiple passports may be the answer to many of fissions and frictions of the new world order, even if bureaucrats and ID card pedlars may hate them.

Ian Williams

Where are the LibDems?

In the past few weeks, ConservativeHome and I have been critical of some Conservatives for, shall be saying, being absent from the headlines. However, this is nothing compared to the LibDems. have they disappeared off the face of planet earth? The Despatch blog makes a good point this morning, saying it is no good just sending out press releases and expecting great media coverage. Not only has Ming Campbell been absent from the headlines for three weeks, so have his key spokespeople.

Iain Dale

Government to Monitor Blogs

The Financial Times reports that the government is about to set up a 'blog monitoring unit' (I kid you not). Another excuse to employ a few more people on the public sector payroll, I guess.

Iain Dale

Precious

A rather precious Iain Dale "guesses" that the government intention to set up a "blog monitoring unit" (as reported by The Financial Times) is "another excuse to employ a few more people on the public sector payroll."

… In fact, this development simply formalises the status quo. After all, not only does the MoD routinely monitor this blog (as does the US Department of Defense) but, through its Defence Headquarters, has also joined our forum and posted several comments from the Defence Procurement Minister (Lord Drayson), responding to issues raised by this blog (and ignored by the MSM).

EU Referendum

Pressure grows for ban on drinking in street

We really have to worry when our policemen and MP's favour the notion of collective punishment. The majority of drinkers, young and old, behave responsibly. Why should they pay more for their alchohol, because a minority misbehave? Why should they be banned from drinking in public places, because a minority are irresponsible? Once again, the authorities want to punish the decent and law-abiding, rather than confront the behaviours of the delinquent.

The Last Ditch

Is Gord’s media honeymoon coming to an end?

Having spent ten years in my early career as an editor with BBC News it strikes me that the quick apology that has been made for parts of the corporation’s coverage of the Tory competition proposals is something of a watershed and might suggest that Brown’s media honeymoon might be running out of steam.

The BBC does not usually react so quickly - especially when the initial source of the complaint was a blog, in this case Iain Dale’s - that even the partial apology is quite a step.

Political Betting

Is There Anyone Out There Who Doesn't Have 3 As?

BBC R5 are doing their annual phone-in on the A Level results. And the jock has just asked desperately if someone could phone who hasn't got three A grades. She's just talked to one girl who has five. A quarter of all grades are now A, and the overall pass rate has reached a staggering 96.9% (see this blog for a comparison with the pass rate in a real exam).

Burning Our Money

Wednesday, 15 August 2007

The Poliblogs 15th August 2007

David Cameron to put healthcare at the heart of his fightback

David Cameron returns from his holiday this weekend, hopefully rested and ready to launch his fightback. The latest opinion polls suggest a widening of Gordon Brown's lead over the Conservatives and today's Daily Mail reports that steel tycoon Lord Paul - worth £280m - has said that he'll give as much as he can afford to fund any autumn General Election. Paul donated £45,000 to Brown's leadership campaign. ConservativeHome has learnt that the NHS will be at the heart of David Cameron's fightback.

Conservative Home

Independence Thoughts

An interesting discussion this lunchtime on 5 Live about Scottish independence (or English independence as some would see it). I must confess to being a bit ambiguous over it all, but I suppose if I have to state a case it is for self-determination, and if the Scots, or the English, felt strongly enough about the issue, I have no real opinion one way or the other.

Bob Piper

Inevitable debt burden

The Independent reports that first-year university students are totting up record debt levels of nearly £6,000 a year and face leaving university owing more than £17,500. This is a 25.5% increase on the debt levels incurred by first year students in previous years.

For some reason the University of Glamorgan has the second highest level of first-year student debt in the country with an average of £7,942. Two of the three universities where students have the least debt are in Scotland - Robert Gordon with £1,103 and Abertay Dundee with £1,123 - where they do not have top-up fees.

Peter Black

Gordon Brown has a big nose, he is Scottish, and he smells

This is the level of some of the responses to John Redwood’s proposals for tax reform and deregulation.

Here I feature Ted Harvey (a sometimes - not here - thoughtful commentator) and Polly Toynbee (who you all know and love).

The Wardman Wire

Why the SNP is Right to Want a Referendum

SNP leader and Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond has published a white paper today outlining three options for the future of Scotland. Predictably all three opposition parties have rounded on him and accused him of trying to wreck the United Kingdom. That may or may not be so, but surely it would be a good thing to allow the Scots to vote on their own future, rather than the argument dragging on needlessly. The white paper outlines three options:-

Iain Dale

Can Gord satisfy the Scots and the English at the same time?

The announcement by Scotland First Minister, the SNP’s Alex Salmond, that there’s to be a “national conversation”, a distinctly new Labour term, on the future governance of Scotland could present a real challenge for Brown.

For on the one hand he wants to head off the SNP pressure and might consider more devolution - but how does he do that without the role of Scottish Labour MPs at Westminster becoming an issue for the Tories to exploit.

Political Betting

SNP & Independence

The Scottish National Party has caused a bit of an upset both north and south of the border by pressing ahead with its manifesto promise of holding a referrendum on Scottish independence.

All the other parties in the Scottish Parliament with the exception of the Greens who are in coalition with the SNP, have promised to jointly fight the proposal and the British establishment is similarly horrified that democracy might actually take place on terms that are not favourable to their agenda.

Wonko’s World

The march of devolution

Scotland's independence will come in small steps, not by a single bound.

Iain MacWhirther

Signs of coalition

And there's more. Signs tonight of a variable response from the SNP's rivals to the White Paper.

Labour want nothing to do with it, the Tories think nothing can be done with the SNP until they sideline independence.

But the Liberal Democrats take a different line. They remain leery of Mr Salmond and his SNP. But they argue that it is significant that the SNP are now canvassing constitutional options short of independence.

Blether with Brian

Legal Challenge to Government as Pressure Grows for Independent 7/7 Enquiry

As I’ve said before, in the absence of any official support, some survivors have had to, by themselves, fend off voracious conspiracy theorists and journalists. Survivor Rachel North has become a focus, via her blog, of much media attention. She has had to deal with a stalker and a legion of conspiracy theorists who simply refuse to take the facts at face value. Some of them have even imaginatively accused her of being a team of MI5 disinformation agents.

Chicken Yoghurt

Google News to start taking comments

This could be an interesting development: Google has announced that their Google News front page is going to start accepting comments from people. However, it won’t be a comment free-for-all; rather the people allowed to comment will be the subjects of the news stories themselves.

Lib Dem Voice

New figures show top-up fees causing student debt problems

Two new surveys on student debt levels point towards top-up fees increasing student debts:

Lib Dem Voice

Heathrow's 3rd runway won't tip the earth into the balance

Alice Miles argues in her Times column on the climate change protests at Heathrow that, "Pretty much anyone without shares in BAA would not wish another runway on that particular part of England (if, indeed, upon any of it)."

I really don’t think this is true, even if some people won’t admit to wanting another runway in green company. I’d wager that the vast majority of those who have been delayed taking off or landing at that airport would welcome something that would cut down on these delays. While everyone I know who flies out of there regualrly is positively clamouring for it.

Coffee House

Phil Taylor: Why is London's public transport so broken?

At the end of July Transport for London's (TfL’s) Annual Report and Accounts was published without fanfare on the their website. TfL was formed, along with the GLA and the London Mayor, by the 1999 GLA Act and is in charge of all public transport in London except for mainline rail services. In July 2003 London Underground, the Tube, became a part of TfL. TfL's 2003 figures were restated to include the Tube so we now have 5 years worth of comparable figures to pore over, an audit trail that makes it increasingly hard for the Mayor to hide the bodies. In this article I try to unearth them.

Conservative Home